A Discovery of Witches (All Souls Trilogy #1)

My first book review for 2018…and it’s not what I’d hoped it would be.

It begins with absence and desire.

It begins with blood and fear.

It begins with a discovery of witches.

The first book I finished in 2018 is A Discover of Witches by Deborah Harkness, which is the first book in her All Souls Trilogy about witches, vampires, and daemons.  The plot of the novel seemed promising. Diana Bishop, who is a descendant of a long line of famous American witches, has tried to accomplish things on her own without relying on her magic.  She studied history at Harvard and Oxford, got tenured at Yale at a very young age, and had published two books about her field of research, that is, the history of science.  Now, back in Oxford, Diana is doing research on the history of alchemy as the forerunner of scientific thinking in preparation for a keynote address she’s to deliver at a conference.  While doing her research, Diana somehow accesses an ancient manuscript belonging to one Elias Ashmole (later referred to only as Ashmole 782), which, even to a non-magic-practicing witch is evidently under some kind of spell. Diana discovers that the manuscript not only depicts alchemical facts and illustrations differently but is also a palimpsest, its pages hiding secret writing that can only be seen with magic.  Unbeknownst to Diana, this accidental discovery is about to change her life forever.

In Diana’s world, creatures such as vampires, witches, and daemons have always coexisted with humans; living and moving among humans but keeping interaction to a minimum lest they be discovered for what they truly are.  So it wasn’t altogether strange that a few days after encountering the strange manuscript, Diana meets Matthew Clairmont, who is a tall, dark, handsome, and mysterious Oxford Fellow, professor, medical doctor, scientists, and vampire (surprise, surprise!) at the library in Oxford.  However, it does come as a surprise to her in the days that follow that not only does she keep “bumping” into Matthew but that the number of otherworldly creatures frequenting the library has doubled as well.  Befriending Diana, Matthew informs her that the manuscript she had recently discovered is a magical text lost long ago regarding the three magical creatures and their origin, evolution, and extinction.  No wonder every witch, vampire, and daemon in the area was drawn to Diana and the manuscript. As Diana tries to understand the significance of the manuscript, as well as her ever-growing powers, she also notices that her forbidden relationship with Matthew is growing stronger and becoming more complicated.

Intelligent, scholarly, and beautiful characters; mysterious manuscripts; historical and medical discoveries and research – what’s not to like right?  Seemed like the perfect combination for an instant bestseller…except that it wasn’t.  A Discovery of Witches is almost 600 pages long, so you’d think that by the end of novel, Diana would have at least found answers to the manuscript, but no!  In the first half of the novel, Diana spends her days going to the library everyday to do research, rowing on the river, running along the river, drinking tea, ad infinitum. Matthew, who can’t wait to get his hands on the manuscript constantly stalks Diana, who tries and fails to avoid him. Everything she knows about vampires tell her he’s dangerous and that she should stay away from him, so of course she ignores all of it.  Eventually they go on a date, followed by another, and another, and yet another…and yoga (yes, yoga!) exclusively for otherworldly creatures, and next thing you know, you’re halfway through the book! The endless pages about Diana and Matthew’s dates and corny courtship is peppered with interesting facts about their magical world and the creatures that inhabit it, Diana’s scholarly research, and Matthew’s medical research on DNA, which are just barely enough to keep you reading in hopes of getting another glimpse of Ashmole 782, which seemed like the main plot of the novel.  About halfway through the novel, the setting changes but it’s still pretty much the same thing – Matthew and Diana sitting around, drinking tea/wine, reading books, smelling each other, and keeping secrets.

I think my biggest peeve about A Discovery of Witches is the characters themselves.  Diana is born from two powerful, intelligent witches; she breezes through her education with affiliation to Harvard, Yale, and Oxford; she is a strong, independent woman who has a photographic memory; and she’s a writer, a researcher, scholar. On top of that, her witch DNA uncharacteristically has every single witch power imaginable:  she can fly, control not just one element, but ALL the elements, she can read minds, talk to the dead, shape shift, go back in time, has telekinesis – you name it, she has it – she’s the chosen one of the Chosen One, the most powerful witch that has ever lived – and yet, she doesn’t want any of it.  She only wants to be a normal, average girl next door. From the way Diana thinks and acts, you’d think she was a clueless teenager.  Imagine my surprise to learn that her character was supposed to be in her mid to late 30’s.

Of course, Matthew Clairmont is no better.  He is the epitome of vampire cliches – more than a thousand years old, he’s been a knight, a stonemason, an architect, a soldier, and now he’s a scientist, a professor, and a medical doctor.  He’s also filthy rich (of course), owning various mansions and estates throughout the world, private jets, and priceless antiques.  This power couple has it all, and yet, they both seem so clueless as to what to do in their present predicament.  Despite being a powerful witch who can do virtually everything, Diana, when not drinking tea or stuffing her face with food, is either incapacitated owing to her uncontrollable magic, an attack from evil witches, or from anxiety.  Meanwhile, Matthew, who is a renowned scholar, completely ignores his breakthroughs scientific discovery to coddle and protect her from every single thing imaginable.  Matthew and Diana become more annoying as their relationship becomes more serious – Matthew justifies his machismo, over protectiveness, and controlling nature as something inherent to vampires, but Diana’s obsessiveness toward Matthew and blatant disregard for her safety and wellbeing in favor of a “love will conquer all” attitude were just as infuriating.

I read this novel during the Christmas-New Year holidays, and looking back, I don’t know how it kept me reading til the wee hours of the morning. I guess I kept hoping that something would happen, but it wasn’t until more than halfway through the book that I realized that nothing was actually going to happen.  The novel starts out promising but becomes increasingly ridiculous toward the end. With the mystery of Ashmole 782 nearly forgotten, A Discovery of Witches changes from a pseudo-historical, pseudo-scientific, semi-intellectual novel into a hokey teenage occult romance.  By the time I got to the last few chapters, I was skimming through the pages just to get the novel over with.

A Discovery of Witches is followed by an equally long sequel, Shadow of Night, and ends with The Book of Life (another door stopper).  Honestly, I don’t know what else the author can write about in the other two novels but I’m not sticking around to find out.  My biggest regret is that I bought all three books before starting A Discovery of Witches – and they weren’t exactly cheap either! Not only was this trilogy a waste of time, it was also a waste of money! Do yourselves a favor and stay away from this trilogy!  A television adaptation  is coming out in 2018, with Matthew Goode (Henry Talbot from Downton Abbey) playing Matthew Clairmont and Teresa Palmer as Diana Bishop.  I can’t help but think Teresa Palmer was given the role because of her resemblance to the actress who played Bella from the Twilight Saga.  The TV adaptation may prove better than the series but I highly doubt it.


A Discovery of Witches (All Souls Trilogy #1) – Deborah Harkness

Penguin; 576 pages (paperback)

Personal rating:  1/5

2 thoughts on “A Discovery of Witches (All Souls Trilogy #1)

  1. I had mixed feelings on this one as well. The second two books aren’t quite as painful as the first–I think the author grew as a writer as the trilogy progressed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s