Uprooted

Uprooted is a fantasy novel by Naomi Novik published in 2015.  Inspired by fairtytales and folklore, Uprooted tells the tale of a young woman, Agnieszka, from a valley surrounded by a dark and mysterious forest known simply as the Wood.  The Wood is home to many evil spirits and creatures ready to abduct, kill, or destroy anyone and anything that comes close enough to its borders.  Fortunately for the villagers, their valley is protected by a powerful wizard who helps them in their time of need and keeps the evil lurking within the Wood at bay.

The Dragon, as he is known to everyone in the valley, is a mysterious and powerful wizard, who despite being guardian of the region of Olshanka, keeps his interaction with the villagers to a minimum, only making an appearance to collect his annual tithing or when his magic is needed in the valley.  For nearly a century, the Dragon has guarded the valley, and every 10 years, from among the young women in the villages, he chooses one to live with him in his tower.  No one knows exactly what he does with them in his tower, but at the end of 10 years, the young women are given a bag of silver as a dowry and returned to their families.  Except that the women who return are never exactly the same as when they were first taken.  Though all swear that they were never violated by the Dragon, all become restless and eventually move to the city to become independent or seek a different life.

The story begins in a year the Dragon is to choose a new young woman to live with him in his tower, and though plain, clumsy, and awkward Agnieszka would be among the young women to be chosen from, she is confident that it won’t be her.  Also among the young women eligible that year was Agineszka’s best friend Kasia, who, as well as being the most beautiful girl in the valley and was gifted with many talents was also kind, graceful, and brave – everything the Dragon looks for in a young woman.  Everyone, as well as Kasia, was sure that she would be the Dragon’s choice.  It comes to a shock to all (though not really to the reader) that on the day of the choosing, the Dragon reluctantly chooses Agnieszka to live with him in his lonely tower.

Surprised, confused, and terrified, Agnieszka was unprepared to be the chosen one, but once in the tower, she is even more surprised at the real reason she was picked out by the Dragon.  The Dragon teaches Agnieszka things about herself that she wasn’t even aware of. In the process, Agnieszka also learns about the dark secrets surrounding her home and the Wood.

Though published in May 2015 and included in several popular “best book of the year” list, including one made by the NPR, I only heard about Uprooted last week in an article about good standalone fantasy novels. Uprooted incorporates Polish folktales from the author’s childhood, and though it’s a story about love, magic, friendship, and loyalty, it’s also a dark tale about betrayal, vengeance, and hate. Despite its heavy themes, gruesome violence, and horrific imagery, Uprooted is a light read compared with other fantasy novels. It is not as serious as Game of Thrones but not as juvenile as The Hunger Games. Though I’ve read a couple of reviews calling it YA, I think it’s really intended for mature readers.

The novel, however interesting, is not without its flaws. To me, its plot is too convoluted, with several different storylines, a few of which the novel would have been better off without. The plot shifts from one focus to another, leading readers in different directions only to return to the main story in the end. The author included elements that did not strengthen the novel and oftentimes failed to elaborate on the important parts of her story. Being a standalone novel, and not a very long one at that, I just felt that there were too many things going on in the plot, and the story took a roundabout way of getting to the important point of the story.

The characters in Uprooted are nothing special either: Agnieszka, the typical young woman who doesn’t think herself beautiful or talented is surprised at every turn of what she can actually accomplish, and the gruff, high and mighty, and all-powerful wizard, who makes no efforts to be nice to Agnieszka, insults her at every opportunity, and constantly shows his irritation at her presence – basically a big jerk.  The other characters are no better; mostly one dimensional and not really fleshed out.

The Dragon has been criticized by readers as a despicable man whose behavior towards Agnieszka borders on the abusive – verbally, at least. I’m not making excuses for the Dragon’s cold behavior or choice of words, but to me, his character is no different from the likes of Wuthering Height‘s Heathcliff or Jane Eyre‘s Mr. Rochester.  And even those two are nastier than the Dragon, whose bark is really worse that his bite.  His bad temper and aloofness seems superficial, and though not a man of warm words and regard, he makes up for it in his actions and intentions.  It’s strange how readers can tolerate, even be attracted to, negative qualities of men in novels that they absolutely won’t tolerate it in real life.  Just another classic example of fiction being better than reality.

Despite its shortcomings, Uprooted is a captivating story that shows a unique take on magic and presents love in all its bittersweet forms and complexities.  I also must admit that I really enjoyed reading this novel.  It’s uncomplicated and simple (despite the convoluted story line.  I know…I can’t explain, you just have to read it!), and the story just carries you through its make-believe world.  It could be all the bad or depressing novels I’ve been reading lately, but I found myself hooked to this novel from the start; I wanted to finish it quickly yet didn’t want it to ever end.

There’s really nothing like a good fantasy novel to escape from mundane reality or boring all-too-serious novels. Every once in a while, it’s good to read something different and refreshing to uplift your reading spirit and take you out of your reading slump.

***

A few months after it was published, it was reported that its movie rights had been bought by Ellen Degeneres.  No news yet on what’s going to happen to it, but I’m looking forward to seeing it adapted to big screen.  I can even imagine someone like Benedict Cumberbatch, Tom Hiddleston, or perhaps Vincent Cassel playingh the part of the Dragon (ehem, Ellen Degeneres, if you’re reading this…..).

***

Uprooted (2015) – Naomi Novik

Del Ray; 443 pages (e-book)

Personal rating:  3/5

2 thoughts on “Uprooted

  1. This is on my reading table and I mean to read it this year. I sent it to a friend for her birthday last summer because I had heard it was so good and she loved it. She thinks I have read it already and I can;t bear to tell her I haven’t. Oops

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s